1932
0
  1. Home
  2. A-Z Publications
  3. Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics
  4. Volume 61, 2023
  5. Article

Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics

Volume 61, 2023

Hydrodynamical Simulations of the Galaxy Population: Enduring Successes and Outstanding Challenges

Abstract

We review the progress in modeling the galaxy population in hydrodynamical simulations of the ΛCDM cosmogony. State-of-the-art simulations now broadly reproduce the observed spatial clustering of galaxies; the distributions of key characteristics, such as mass, size, and SFR; and scaling relations connecting diverse properties to mass. Such improvements engender confidence in the insight drawn from simulations. Many important outcomes, however, particularly the properties of circumgalactic gas, are sensitive to the details of the subgrid models used to approximate the macroscopic effects of unresolved physics, such as feedback processes. We compare the outcomes of leading simulation suites with observations, and with each other, to identify the enduring successes they have cultivated and the outstanding challenges to be tackled with the next generation of models. Our key conclusions include the following:

  • ▪  Realistic galaxies can be reproduced by calibrating the ill-constrained parameters of subgrid feedback models. Feedback is dominated by stars and black holes in low-mass and high-mass galaxies, respectively.
  • ▪  Adjusting or disabling the processes implemented in simulations can elucidate their impact on observables, but outcomes can be degenerate.
  • ▪  Similar galaxy populations can emerge in simulations with dissimilar feedback implementations. However, these models generally predict markedly different gas flow rates into, and out of, galaxies and their halos. CGM observations are thus a promising means of breaking this degeneracy and guiding the development of new feedback models.
Keyword(s): galaxies, galaxy formation, galaxy halos, gas, numerical simulations
Loading

Article metrics loading...

/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-041923-043618
2023-08-18
2024-04-28
Loading full text...

Full text loading...

/deliver/fulltext/astro/61/1/annurev-astro-041923-043618.html?itemId=/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-041923-043618&mimeType=html&fmt=ahah

Literature Cited

  1. Abadi MG, Navarro JF, Steinmetz M, Eke VR. 2003a. Ap. J. 597:21–34
  2. Abadi MG, Navarro JF, Steinmetz M, Eke VR. 2003b. Ap. J. 591:2499–514
  3. Abel T, Bryan GL, Norman ML. 2002. Science 295:555293–98
  4. Agertz O, Moore B, Stadel J et al. 2007. MNRAS 380:3963–78
  5. Agertz O, Pontzen A, Read JI et al. 2020. MNRAS 491:21656–72
  6. Aguirre A, Hernquist L, Schaye J et al. 2001. Ap. J. 560:2599–605
  7. Anglés-Alcázar D, Davé R, Faucher-Giguère CA, Özel F, Hopkins PF. 2017. MNRAS 464:32840–53
  8. Appleby S, Davé R, Kraljic K, Anglés-Alcázar D, Narayanan D. 2020. MNRAS 494:46053–71
  9. Artale MC, Pedrosa SE, Trayford JW et al. 2017. MNRAS 470:21771–87
  10. Bagla JS, Prasad J. 2006. MNRAS 370:2993–1002
  11. Bahé YM, Barnes DJ, Dalla Vecchia C et al. 2017. MNRAS 470:44186–208
  12. Bahé YM, Crain RA, Kauffmann G et al. 2016. MNRAS 456:1115–36
  13. Bahé YM, Schaye J, Schaller M et al. 2022. MNRAS 516:167–84
  14. Barnes J, Hut P. 1986. Nature 324:6096446–49
  15. Bate MR, Burkert A. 1997. MNRAS 288:41060–72
  16. Beckmann RS, Devriendt J, Slyz A et al. 2017. MNRAS 472:949–65
  17. Behroozi P, Wechsler RH, Hearin AP, Conroy C. 2019. MNRAS 488:33143–94
  18. Benítez-Llambay A, Navarro JF, Abadi MG et al. 2013. Ap. J. Lett. 763:2L41
  19. Best PN, Heckman TM. 2012. MNRAS 421:21569–82
  20. Black JH. 1987. Interstellar Process 134:731–44
  21. Boehringer H, Hensler G. 1989. Astron. Astrophys. 215:147–49
  22. Bondi H, Hoyle F. 1944. MNRAS 104:273
  23. Booth CM, Schaye J. 2009. MNRAS 398:53–74
  24. Booth CM, Schaye J. 2010. MNRAS 405:L1–5
  25. Borrow J, Kannan R, Garaldi E et al. 2022a. arXiv:2212.03255
  26. Borrow J, Schaller M, Bahe YM et al. 2022b. arXiv:2211.08442
  27. Borrow J, Schaller M, Bower RG, Schaye J. 2022c. MNRAS 511:22367–89
  28. Bower RG, Schaye J, Frenk CS et al. 2017. MNRAS 465:32–44
  29. Bustamante S, Springel V. 2019. MNRAS 490:34133–53
  30. Butsky IS, Werk JK, Tchernyshyov K et al. 2022. Ap. J. 935:269
  31. Carilli CL, Taylor GB. 2002. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 40:319–48
  32. Carraro G, Lia C, Chiosi C. 1998. MNRAS 297:41021–40
  33. Carrier J, Greengard L, Rokhlin V. 1988. SIAM J. Sci. Stat. Comput. 9:4669–86
  34. Chabrier G. 2003. Publ. Astron. Soc. Pac. 115:809763–95
  35. Chaves-Montero J, Angulo RE, Schaye J et al. 2016. MNRAS 460:33100–18
  36. Chisholm J, Tremonti CA, Leitherer C, Chen Y. 2016a. MNRAS 463:541–56
  37. Chisholm J, Tremonti CA, Leitherer C, Chen Y, Wofford A. 2016b. MNRAS 457:33133–61
  38. Christensen CR, Davé R, Governato F et al. 2016. Ap. J. 824:57
  39. Churazov E, Sazonov S, Sunyaev R et al. 2005. MNRAS 363:L91–95
  40. Cicone C, Maiolino R, Sturm E et al. 2014. Astron. Astrophys. 562:A21
  41. Conroy C, Gunn JE, White M. 2009. Ap. J. 699:486–506
  42. Conroy C, Wechsler RH, Kravtsov AV. 2006. Ap. J. 647:201–14
  43. Correa CA, Schaye J, Clauwens B et al. 2017. MNRAS 472:L45–49
  44. Crain RA, Bahé YM, Lagos CdP et al. 2017. MNRAS 464:44204–26
  45. Crain RA, Eke VR, Frenk CS et al. 2007. MNRAS 377:41–49
  46. Crain RA, Schaye J, Bower RG et al. 2015. MNRAS 450:21937–61
  47. Crain RA, Theuns T, Dalla Vecchia C et al. 2009. MNRAS 399:41773–94
  48. Creasey P, Theuns T, Bower RG, Lacey CG. 2011. MNRAS 415:43706–20
  49. Cui W, Knebe A, Yepes G et al. 2018. MNRAS 480:32898–915
  50. Curtis M, Sijacki D. 2015. MNRAS 454:43445–63
  51. Curtis-Lake E, Carniani S, Cameron A et al. 2023. Nat. Astron. 7:622–32
  52. Dalgarno A, McCray RA. 1972. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 10:375
  53. Dalla Vecchia C, Schaye J 2008. MNRAS 387:41431–44
  54. Dalla Vecchia C, Schaye J 2012. MNRAS 426:140–58
  55. Davé R. 2008. MNRAS 385:147–60
  56. Davé R, Anglés-Alcázar D, Narayanan D et al. 2019. MNRAS 486:22827–49
  57. Davé R, Crain RA, Stevens ARH et al. 2020. MNRAS 497:146–66
  58. Davé R, Hernquist L, Katz N, Weinberg DH. 1999. Ap. J. 511:2521–45
  59. Davé R, Spergel DN, Steinhardt PJ, Wandelt BD. 2001. Ap. J. 547:2574–89
  60. Davies JJ, Crain RA, Oppenheimer BD, Schaye J. 2020. MNRAS 491:34462–80
  61. Davies JJ, Crain RA, Pontzen A. 2021. MNRAS 501:236–53
  62. Davies JJ, Pontzen A, Crain RA. 2022. MNRAS 515:1430–43
  63. Davies LJM, Robotham ASG, Lagos CdP et al. 2019. MNRAS 483:45444–58
  64. De Rossi ME, Bower RG, Font AS, Schaye J, Theuns T. 2017. MNRAS 472:33354–77
  65. Di Matteo T, Colberg J, Springel V, Hernquist L, Sijacki D. 2008. Ap. J. 676:33–53
  66. Diemer B, Stevens ARH, Forbes JC et al. 2018. Ap. J. Suppl. 238:233
  67. Donnari M, Pillepich A, Nelson D et al. 2019. MNRAS 485:44817–40
  68. Donnari M, Pillepich A, Nelson D et al. 2021. MNRAS 506:44760–80
  69. Dubois Y, Devriendt J, Slyz A, Teyssier R. 2012. MNRAS 420:32662–83
  70. Dubois Y, Peirani S, Pichon C et al. 2016. MNRAS 463:43948–64
  71. Dubois Y, Pichon C, Welker C et al. 2014. MNRAS 444:21453–68
  72. Dubois Y, Teyssier R. 2008. Astron. Astrophys. 477:79–94
  73. Dubois Y, Volonteri M, Silk J et al. 2015. MNRAS 452:21502–18
  74. Efstathiou G. 1992. MNRAS 256:243P–47P
  75. Efstathiou G, Davis M, White SDM, Frenk CS. 1985. Ap. J. Suppl. 57:241–60
  76. Faber SM, Jackson RE. 1976. Ap. J. 204:668–83
  77. Faucher-Giguère CA, Lidz A, Zaldarriaga M, Hernquist L. 2009. Ap. J. 703:21416–43
  78. Faucher-Giguère CA, Oh P. 2023. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 61:131–95
  79. Feldmann R, Quataert E, Faucher-Giguère CA et al. 2023. MNRAS 522:33831–60
  80. Feng Y, Di-Matteo T, Croft RA et al. 2016. MNRAS 455:32778–91
  81. Ferland GJ, Chatzikos M, Guzmán F et al. 2017. Rev. Mex. Astron. Astrofis. 53:385–438
  82. Ferrero I, Navarro JF, Abadi MG et al. 2017. MNRAS 464:4736–46
  83. Fielding DB, Ostriker EC, Bryan GL, Jermyn AS. 2020. Ap. J. Lett. 894:2L24
  84. François P, Matteucci F, Cayrel R et al. 2004. Astron. Astrophys. 421:613–21
  85. Frenk CS, White SDM, Bode P et al. 1999. Ap. J. 525:2554–82
  86. Fumagalli M, Hennawi JF, Prochaska JX et al. 2014. Ap. J. 780:74
  87. Furlanetto SR, Schaye J, Springel V, Hernquist L. 2005. Ap. J. 622:7–27
  88. Furlong M, Bower RG, Crain RA et al. 2017. MNRAS 465:722–38
  89. Furlong M, Bower RG, Theuns T et al. 2015. MNRAS 450:44486–504
  90. Gallazzi A, Charlot S, Brinchmann J, White SDM, Tremonti CA. 2005. MNRAS 362:41–58
  91. Garnier E, Adams N, Sagaut P. 2009. Large Eddy Simulation for Compressible Flows Berlin: Springer
  92. Genel S, Bryan GL, Springel V et al. 2019. Ap. J. 871:21
  93. Genel S, Nelson D, Pillepich A et al. 2018. MNRAS 474:33976–96
  94. Genel S, Vogelsberger M, Springel V et al. 2014. MNRAS 445:175–200
  95. Gerritsen JPE, Icke V. 1997. Astron. Astrophys. 325:972–86
  96. Gingold RA, Monaghan JJ. 1977. MNRAS 181:375–89
  97. Gnedin NY, Hollon N. 2012. Ap. J. Suppl. 202:213
  98. Gnedin NY, Tassis K, Kravtsov AV. 2009. Ap. J. 697:55–67
  99. Governato F, Mayer L, Wadsley J et al. 2004. Ap. J. 607:2688–96
  100. Governato F, Willman B, Mayer L et al. 2007. MNRAS 374:41479–94
  101. Greggio L. 2005. Astron. Astrophys. 441:31055–78
  102. Greggio L, Renzini A. 1983. Astron. Astrophys. 118:2217–22
  103. Greif TH, Glover SCO, Bromm V, Klessen RS. 2009. MNRAS 392:41381–87
  104. Guedes J, Callegari S, Madau P, Mayer L. 2011. Ap. J. 742:276
  105. Gunn JE, Gott J. Richard I. 1972. Ap. J. 176:1
  106. Guo Q, Gonzalez-Perez V, Guo Q et al. 2016. MNRAS 461:43457–82
  107. Gutcke TA, Pakmor R, Naab T, Springel V. 2022. MNRAS 513:1372–85
  108. Haardt F, Madau P. 1996. Ap. J. 461:20
  109. Haardt F, Madau P 2001. Modelling the UV/X-ray cosmic background with CUBA. Clusters of Galaxies and the High Redshift Universe Observed in X-rays DM Neumann JTV Tran.
     [Google Scholar]
  110. Haardt F, Madau P. 2012. Ap. J. 746:2125
  111. Haas MR, Schaye J, Jeeson-Daniel A 2012. MNRAS 419:32133–46
  112. Habouzit M, Li Y, Somerville RS et al. 2021. MNRAS 503:21940–75
  113. Hahn O, Abel T. 2011. MNRAS 415:32101–21
  114. Hahn O, Rampf C, Uhlemann C. 2021. MNRAS 503:426–45
  115. Haider M, Steinhauser D, Vogelsberger M et al. 2016. MNRAS 457:33024–35
  116. Henden NA, Puchwein E, Shen S, Sijacki D. 2018. MNRAS 479:45385–412
  117. Herzog G, Benitez-Llambay A, Fumagalli M. 2022. MNRAS 518:6305–17
  118. Hirschmann M, Dolag K, Saro A et al. 2014. MNRAS 442:32304–24
  119. Hockney RW, Eastwood JW. 1981. Computer Simulation Using Particles Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press
  120. Hopkins PF. 2013. MNRAS 428:42840–56
  121. Hopkins PF. 2015. MNRAS 450:53–110
  122. Hopkins PF, Kereš D, Oñorbe J et al. 2014. MNRAS 445:581–603
  123. Hopkins PF, Wetzel A, Kereš D et al. 2018. MNRAS 480:800–63
  124. Huang S, Katz N, Scannapieco E et al. 2020. MNRAS 497:32586–604
  125. Huertas-Company M, Rodriguez-Gomez V, Nelson D et al. 2019. MNRAS 489:21859–79
  126. Hummels CB, Smith BD, Hopkins PF et al. 2019. Ap. J. 882:2156
  127. Icaza-Lizaola M, Bower RG, Norberg P et al. 2021. MNRAS 507:34584–602
  128. Jahnke K, Macciò AV. 2011. Ap. J. 734:292
  129. Jeans JH. 1928. Astronomy and Cosmogony Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Univ. Press
  130. Jenkins A. 2010. MNRAS 403:41859–72
  131. Jenkins A. 2013. MNRAS 434:32094–120
  132. Ji S, Chan TK, Hummels CB et al. 2020. MNRAS 496:44221–38
  133. Jo Y, Genel S, Wandelt B et al. 2023. Ap. J. 944:67
  134. Kang X, Jing YP, Mo HJ, Börner G. 2005. Ap. J. 631:21–40
  135. Kannan R, Springel V, Hernquist L et al. 2022. arXiv:2210.10066
  136. Katz H, Ramsoy M, Rosdahl J et al. 2020. MNRAS 494:22200–20
  137. Katz N, Gunn JE. 1991. Ap. J. 377:365
  138. Katz N, Weinberg DH, Hernquist L. 1996. Ap. J. Suppl. 105:19
  139. Kaviraj S, Laigle C, Kimm T et al. 2017. MNRAS 467:44739–52
  140. Kay ST, Thomas PA, Theuns T. 2003. MNRAS 343:2608–18
  141. Keller BW, Wadsley J, Benincasa SM, Couchman HMP. 2014. MNRAS 442:43013–25
  142. Keller BW, Wadsley JW, Wang L, Kruijssen JMD. 2019. MNRAS 482:22244–61
  143. Kennicutt RC Jr. 1998. Ap. J. 498:2541–52
  144. Khandai N, Di Matteo T, Croft R et al. 2015. MNRAS 450:21349–74
  145. Kim CG, Ostriker EC. 2017. Ap. J. 846:2133
  146. Kim J-h, Abel T, Agertz O et al. 2014. Ap. J. Suppl. 210:14
  147. King A, Nealon R. 2021. MNRAS 502:L1–5
  148. Kormendy J, Ho LC. 2013. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 51:511–653
  149. Kugel R, Borrow J. 2022. J. Open Source Softw. 7:724240
  150. Labbé I, van Dokkum P, Nelson E et al. 2023. Nature 616:266–69
  151. Lackner CN, Cen R, Ostriker JP, Joung MR. 2012. MNRAS 425:641–56
  152. Lagos CdP, Crain RA, Schaye J et al. 2015. MNRAS 452:43815–37
  153. Lagos CdP, Theuns T, Schaye J et al. 2016. MNRAS 459:32632–50
  154. Larson RB. 1974. MNRAS 169:229–46
  155. Leitherer J, Schaerer D, Goldader JD et al. 1999. Ap. J. Suppl. 123:3–40
  156. Leja J, Carnall AC, Johnson BD, Conroy C, Speagle JS. 2019. Ap. J. 876:3
  157. Lewis A, Challinor A. 2011. CAMB: Code for Anisotropies in the Microwave Background. Astrophysics Source Code Library record ascl:1102.026
     [Google Scholar]
  158. Li C, White SDM. 2009. MNRAS 398:42177–87
  159. Lopez LA, Krumholz MR, Bolatto AD, Prochaska JX, Ramirez-Ruiz E. 2011. Ap. J. 731:291
  160. Lucy LB. 1977. Astron. J. 82:1013–24
  161. Ludlow AD, Schaye J, Schaller M, Richings J. 2019. MNRAS 488:L123–28
  162. Machacek ME, Bryan GL, Abel T. 2001. Ap. J. 548:2509–21
  163. Madau P, Dickinson M. 2014. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 52:415–86
  164. Maiolino R, Gallerani S, Neri R et al. 2012. MNRAS 425:L66–70
  165. Mannucci F, Della Valle M, Panagia N 2006. MNRAS 370:2773–83
  166. Maoz D, Mannucci F, Nelemans G. 2014. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 52:107–70
  167. Marasco A, Crain RA, Schaye J et al. 2016. MNRAS 461:32630–49
  168. Martín-Navarro I, Pillepich A, Nelson D et al. 2021. Nature 594:7862187–90
  169. Matthee J, Schaye J. 2019. MNRAS 484:915–32
  170. McAlpine S, Helly JC, Schaller M et al. 2016. Astron. Comput. 15:72–89
  171. McCarthy IG, Schaye J, Bird S, Le Brun AMC 2017. MNRAS 465:32936–65
  172. McCarthy IG, Schaye J, Font AS et al. 2012. MNRAS 427:379–92
  173. McCourt M, Oh SP, O'Leary R, Madigan AM. 2018. MNRAS 473:45407–31
  174. McGaugh SS, Schombert JM, Bothun GD, de Blok WJG. 2000. Ap. J. Lett. 533:2L99–102
  175. McKee CF, Ostriker JP. 1977. Ap. J. 218:148–69
  176. Menon H, Wesolowski L, Zheng G et al. 2015. Comput. Astrophys. Cosmol. 2:1
  177. Merloni A, Heinz S. 2008. MNRAS 388:31011–30
  178. Metha B, Trenti M. 2020. MNRAS 495:266–77
  179. Mihos JC, Hernquist L. 1994. Ap. J. 437:611
  180. Miralda-Escudé J. 2005. Ap. J. Lett. 620:2L91–94
  181. Mitchell NL, McCarthy IG, Bower RG, Theuns T, Crain RA. 2009. MNRAS 395:180–96
  182. Mitchell PD, Schaye J, Bower RG, Crain RA. 2020. MNRAS 494:33971–97
  183. Monaghan JJ. 1985. J. Comput. Phys. 60:2253–62
  184. Monaghan JJ. 1997. J. Comput. Phys. 136:2298–307
  185. Muratov AL, Kereš D, Faucher-Giguère CA et al. 2015. MNRAS 454:32691–713
  186. Navarro JF, Benz W. 1991. Ap. J. 380:320
  187. Navarro JF, Frenk CS, White SDM. 1995. MNRAS 275:56–66
  188. Navarro JF, Steinmetz M. 1997. Ap. J. 478:13–28
  189. Navarro JF, Steinmetz M. 2000. Ap. J. 538:2477–88
  190. Navarro JF, White SDM. 1993. MNRAS 265:271
  191. Nelson D, Kauffmann G, Pillepich A et al. 2018a. MNRAS 477:450–79
  192. Nelson D, Pillepich A, Genel S et al. 2015. Astron. Comput. 13:12–37
  193. Nelson D, Pillepich A, Springel V et al. 2018b. MNRAS 475:624–47
  194. Nelson D, Springel V, Pillepich A et al. 2019. Comput. Astrophys. Cosmol. 6:2
  195. Noeske KG, Weiner BJ, Faber SM et al. 2007. Ap. J. Lett. 660:L43–46
  196. Okamoto T, Eke VR, Frenk CS, Jenkins A. 2005. MNRAS 363:41299–314
  197. Omukai K, Tsuribe T, Schneider R, Ferrara A. 2005. Ap. J. 626:2627–43
  198. Oppenheimer BD, Crain RA, Schaye J et al. 2016. MNRAS 460:22157–79
  199. Oppenheimer BD, Davé R. 2008. MNRAS 387:2577–600
  200. Oppenheimer BD, Davé R, Kereš D et al. 2010. MNRAS 406:42325–38
  201. Oppenheimer BD, Schaye J, Crain RA, Werk JK, Richings AJ. 2018. MNRAS 481:835–59
  202. Orlando S, Peres G, Reale F et al. 2005. Astron. Astrophys. 444:2505–19
  203. O'Shea BW, Nagamine K, Springel V, Hernquist L, Norman ML. 2005. Ap. J. Suppl. 160:1–27
  204. Pakmor R, Springel V, Coles JP et al. 2022. arXiv:2210.10060
  205. Pallottini A, Ferrara A, Gallerani S et al. 2017. MNRAS 465:32540–58
  206. Pasha I, Mandelker N, van den Bosch FC, Springel V, van de Voort F. 2023. MNRAS 520:22692–708
  207. Peeples MS, Corlies L, Tumlinson J et al. 2019. Ap. J. 873:2129
  208. Péroux C, Howk JC. 2020. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 58:363–406
  209. Péroux C, Nelson D, van de Voort F et al. 2020. MNRAS 499:22462–73
  210. Pfeffer J, Kruijssen JMD, Crain RA, Bastian N. 2018. MNRAS 475:44309–46
  211. Pillepich A, Nelson D, Hernquist L et al. 2018a. MNRAS 475:648–75
  212. Pillepich A, Springel V, Nelson D et al. 2018b. MNRAS 473:34077–106
  213. Piotrowska JM, Bluck AFL, Maiolino R, Peng Y. 2022. MNRAS 512:1052–90
  214. Ploeckinger S, Schaye J. 2020. MNRAS 497:44857–83
  215. Pontzen A, Governato F. 2012. MNRAS 421:43464–71
  216. Portinari L, Moretti A, Chiosi C, Sommer-Larsen J. 2004. Ap. J. 604:2579–95
  217. Power C, Navarro JF, Jenkins A et al. 2003. MNRAS 338:14–34
  218. Price DJ. 2008. J. Comput. Phys. 227:2410040–57
  219. Price DJ. 2012. J. Comput. Phys. 231:3759–94
  220. Rahmati A, Pawlik AH, Raičević M, Schaye J. 2013. MNRAS 430:32427–45
  221. Rahmati A, Schaye J, Bower RG et al. 2015. MNRAS 452:22034–56
  222. Reed DS, Bower R, Frenk CS, Jenkins A, Theuns T. 2007. MNRAS 374:2–15
  223. Richings AJ, Schaye J, Oppenheimer BD. 2014. MNRAS 440:43349–69
  224. Ritchie BW, Thomas PA. 2001. MNRAS 323:3743–56
  225. Robertson A, Massey R, Eke V. 2017. MNRAS 467:44719–30
  226. Robertson BE, Kravtsov AV. 2008. Ap. J. 680:21083–111
  227. Rodriguez-Gomez V, Snyder GF, Lotz JM et al. 2019. MNRAS 483:34140–59
  228. Romano D, Chiappini C, Matteucci F, Tosi M. 2005. Astron. Astrophys. 430:491–505
  229. Rosas-Guevara Y, Tissera P, Lagos CdP, Paillas E, Padilla N. 2022. MNRAS 517:712–31
  230. Rosen AL, Lopez LA, Krumholz MR, Ramirez-Ruiz E. 2014. MNRAS 442:32701–16
  231. Rosswog S. 2020. MNRAS 498:34230–55
  232. Saintonge A, Catinella B. 2022. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 60:319–61
  233. Sales LV, Navarro JF, Oman K et al. 2017. MNRAS 464:22419–28
  234. Scannapieco C, Wadepuhl M, Parry OH et al. 2012. MNRAS 423:1726–49
  235. Schaller M, Frenk CS, Bower RG et al. 2015. MNRAS 451:21247–67
  236. Schaller M, Gonnet P, Chalk ABG, Draper PW. 2016. PASC '16: Proceedings of the Platform for Advanced Scientific Computing Conference, Lausanne, Switz., June 8–10 Art. no. 2. https://doi.org/10.1145/2929908.2929916
    [Crossref]
  237. Schaye J, Crain RA, Bower RG et al. 2015. MNRAS 446:521–54
  238. Schaye J, Dalla Vecchia C. 2008. MNRAS 383:31210–22
  239. Schaye J, Dalla Vecchia C, Booth CM et al. 2010. MNRAS 402:31536–60
  240. Schirber M, Miralda-Escudé J, McDonald P. 2004. Ap. J. 610:105–16
  241. Schmidt M. 1959. Ap. J. 129:243
  242. Sembolini F, Yepes G, Pearce FR et al. 2016. MNRAS 457:4063–80
  243. Semenov VA, Kravtsov AV, Gnedin NY. 2016. Ap. J. 826:2200
  244. Shakura NI, Sunyaev RA. 1973. Astron. Astrophys. 24:337–55
  245. Shlosman I, Begelman MC, Frank J. 1990. Nature 345:6277679–86
  246. Sijacki D, Springel V, Di Matteo T, Hernquist L. 2007. MNRAS 380:3877–900
  247. Simpson CM, Grand RJJ, Gómez FA et al. 2018. MNRAS 478:548–67
  248. Smith B, Sigurdsson S, Abel T. 2008. MNRAS 385:31443–54
  249. Smith BD, Bryan GL, Glover SCO et al. 2017. MNRAS 466:22217–34
  250. Smith MJ, Geach JE. 2023. R. Soc. Open Sci. 10:5221454
  251. Snyder GF, Torrey P, Lotz JM et al. 2015. MNRAS 454:21886–908
  252. Sommer-Larsen J, Gelato S, Vedel H. 1999. Ap. J. 519:2501–12
  253. Sorini D, Davé R, Cui W, Appleby S. 2022. MNRAS 516:883–906
  254. Sparre M, Hayward CC, Feldmann R et al. 2017. MNRAS 466:88–104
  255. Springel V. 2010a. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 48:391–430
  256. Springel V. 2010b. MNRAS 401:2791–851
  257. Springel V, Di Matteo T, Hernquist L. 2005. MNRAS 361:3776–94
  258. Springel V, Hernquist L. 2003. MNRAS 339:2289–311
  259. Springel V, Pakmor R, Pillepich A et al. 2018. MNRAS 475:676–98
  260. Steinmetz M, Mueller E. 1994. Astron. Astrophys. 281:3L97–100
  261. Stevens ARH, Diemer B, Lagos CdP et al. 2019. MNRAS 483:45334–54
  262. Stinson G, Seth A, Katz N et al. 2006. MNRAS 373:31074–90
  263. Sun M, Voit GM, Donahue M et al. 2009. Ap. J. 693:21142–72
  264. Sutherland RS, Dopita MA. 1993. Ap. J. Suppl. 88:253
  265. Tasker EJ, Brunino R, Mitchell NL et al. 2008. MNRAS 390:31267–81
  266. Teyssier R. 2015. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 53:325–64
  267. Theis C, Burkert A, Hensler G. 1992. Astron. Astrophys. 265:2465–77
  268. Theuns T, Leonard A, Efstathiou G, Pearce FR, Thomas PA. 1998. MNRAS 301:2478–502
  269. Thob ACR, Crain RA, McCarthy IG et al. 2019. MNRAS 485:972–87
  270. Tornatore L, Borgani S, Dolag K, Matteucci F. 2007. MNRAS 382:31050–72
  271. Torrey P, Vogelsberger M, Marinacci F et al. 2019. MNRAS 484:45587–607
  272. Trayford JW, Camps P, Theuns T et al. 2017. MNRAS 470:771–99
  273. Trayford JW, Theuns T, Bower RG et al. 2015. MNRAS 452:32879–96
  274. Trebitsch M, Blaizot J, Rosdahl J, Devriendt J, Slyz A. 2017. MNRAS 470:224–39
  275. Tremmel M, Governato F, Volonteri M, Quinn TR. 2015. MNRAS 451:21868–74
  276. Tremmel M, Karcher M, Governato F et al. 2017. MNRAS 470:1121–39
  277. Tremmel M, Quinn TR, Ricarte A et al. 2019. MNRAS 483:33336–62
  278. Tremonti CA, Heckman TM, Kauffmann G et al. 2004. Ap. J. 613:2898–913
  279. Truelove JK, Klein RI, McKee CF et al. 1997. Ap. J. Lett. 489:2L179–83
  280. Tully RB, Fisher JR. 1977. Astron. Astrophys. 54:661–73
  281. Tumlinson J, Peeples MS, Werk JK. 2017. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 55:389–432
  282. Tumlinson J, Thom C, Werk JK et al. 2011. Science 334:6058948
  283. Uhlig M, Pfrommer C, Sharma M et al. 2012. MNRAS 423:32374–96
  284. van de Voort F, Bahé YM, Bower RG et al. 2017. MNRAS 466:33460–71
  285. van de Voort F, Bieri R, Pakmor R et al. 2021. MNRAS 501:44888–902
  286. van de Voort F, Pakmor R, Grand RJJ et al. 2020. MNRAS 494:44867–83
  287. van de Voort F, Schaye J. 2012. MNRAS 423:42991–3010
  288. van de Voort F, Springel V, Mandelker N, van den Bosch FC, Pakmor R. 2019. MNRAS 482:L85–89
  289. van der Wel A, Franx M, van Dokkum PG et al. 2014. Ap. J. 788:28
  290. Vandenbroucke B, De Rijcke S. 2016. Astron. Comput. 16:109–30
  291. Vasiliev EO. 2011. MNRAS 414:43145–57
  292. Vikhlinin A, Markevitch M, Murray SS et al. 2005. Ap. J. 628:2655–72
  293. Villaescusa-Navarro F, Anglés-Alcázar D, Genel S et al. 2021. Ap. J. 915:71
  294. Villaescusa-Navarro F, Genel S, Anglés-Alcázar D et al. 2023. Ap. J. Suppl. 265:54
  295. Vogelsberger M, Genel S, Sijacki D et al. 2013. MNRAS 436:43031–67
  296. Vogelsberger M, Genel S, Springel V et al. 2014. MNRAS 444:21518–47
  297. Volonteri M, Habouzit M, Colpi M. 2021. Nat. Rev. Phys. 3:11732–43
  298. Wadsley JW, Keller BW, Quinn T. 2017. MNRAS 471:2357–69
  299. Wadsley JW, Veeravalli G, Couchman HMP. 2008. MNRAS 387:427–38
  300. Weil ML, Eke VR, Efstathiou G. 1998. MNRAS 300:3773–89
  301. Weinberger R, Springel V, Hernquist L et al. 2017. MNRAS 465:33291–308
  302. Weinberger R, Springel V, Pakmor R. 2020. Ap. J. Suppl. 248:232
  303. Wendland H. 1995. Adv. Comput. Math.4389–96
  304. Werk JK, Prochaska JX, Thom C et al. 2013. Ap. J. Suppl. 204:217
  305. Werk JK, Prochaska JX, Tumlinson J et al. 2014. Ap. J. 792:8
  306. Wheeler C, Hopkins PF, Pace AB et al. 2019. MNRAS 490:34447–63
  307. White SDM. 1994. arXiv:astro–ph/9410043
  308. Wiersma RPC, Schaye J, Smith BD. 2009a. MNRAS 393:99–107
  309. Wiersma RPC, Schaye J, Theuns T, Dalla Vecchia C, Tornatore L 2009b. MNRAS 399:2574–600
  310. Wijers NA, Schaye J, Oppenheimer BD, Crain RA, Nicastro F. 2019. MNRAS 488:22947–69
  311. Wise JH, Cen R. 2009. Ap. J. 693:984–99
  312. Wright AH, Robotham ASG, Driver SP et al. 2017. MNRAS 470:283–302
  313. Wright RJ, Lagos CdP, Power C, Mitchell PD. 2020. MNRAS 498:21668–92
  314. Wright RJ, Lagos CdP, Power C et al. 2022. MNRAS 516:22891–912
  315. Yang H, Gao L, Frenk CS et al. 2023. MNRAS 518:45253–59
  316. Yepes G, Kates R, Khokhlov A, Klypin A. 1997. MNRAS 284:235–56
  317. Yun K, Pillepich A, Zinger E et al. 2019. MNRAS 483:1042–66
  318. Zavala J, Frenk CS, Bower R et al. 2016. MNRAS 460:44466–82
  319. Zuo L. 1992. MNRAS 258:36–44
/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-041923-043618
Loading
Hydrodynamical Simulations of the Galaxy Population: Enduring Successes and Outstanding Challenges
Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics 61, 473 (2023); https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-astro-041923-043618
/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-041923-043618
/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-041923-043618
Loading

Data & Media loading...

  • Article Type: Review Article

Most Cited Most Cited RSS feed

This is a required field
Please enter a valid email address
Approval was a Success
Invalid data
An Error Occurred
Approval was partially successful, following selected items could not be processed due to error